When bigots began making Islamophobic demands that Mayor Zohran Mamdani stay away from the 9/11 commemoration events, City Council Speaker Julie Menin rose to his defense, calling the insults "absolutely inappropriate." And when Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu accused the mayor of being an antisemite who supports terrorists, Menin suggested Netanyahu's rhetoric was dangerous: "This idea of what the prime minister said can really incite violence. We cannot have this."
But on Monday afternoon, Speaker Menin lent her credibility to a forum that was honoring people who have spent the last several years trading in Islamophobia and anti-Palestinian rhetoric. The event was not included on Menin's public schedule emailed to the City Hall press corps.
Speaker Menin was given headliner treatment at Touro University's annual antisemitism symposium, alongside actor Debra Messing, who said she didn't vote for Zohran Mamdani in the 2025 mayoral primary because he "celebrated 9/11" and who spent Election Day 2025 re-sharing numerous Islamophobic memes that referred to Mamdani as an "actual communist jihadist" and stated that Muslims are "commanded to lie if it means spreading Islam." Messing spoke towards the end of the event, and also received an award. (As did singer and MAGA donor Gloria Gaynor.)
Another speaker at this year's symposium: Mort Klein, the national president of the Zionist Organization of America, who has proudly used the slur "filthy Arab," praised President Donald Trump's plans to level Gaza, and called Mamdani a "Jew-hater."
While New York City's political leaders who marched in this year's Israel Day Parade—including Speaker Menin—rushed to condemn the presence of Israeli finance minister Bezalel Smotrich, Klein defended him. Smotrich has called for the "total annihilation" of Palestinian cities in Gaza.


