There’s Still a Clemency Grinch in the Governor’s Office
Governor Kathy Hochul is still extremely stingy with pardons and commutations.
9:49 AM EST on December 22, 2022
One year ago, after she granted pardons and commutations to 10 New Yorkers, Governor Kathy Hochul promised to overhaul the state's broken clemency process. She pledged to hire new staff to review the thousands of applications from currently incarcerated New Yorkers who have served time and are eligible for compassionate release, or those who need pardons to avoid deportation, or who simply deserve to have their records wiped clean. The goal was to grant clemency on a "rolling basis" throughout the year, instead of making the announcement at the end of the calendar year, like her predecessor.
"I am granting clemency to these deserving individuals who have exemplified rehabilitation, and I am committed to increased transparency and accountability in this process going forward," Hochul said in a release. "No one should be defined by their worst mistake, and these individuals have worked tirelessly to atone for theirs."
Seven months after Hochul made that announcement, she still hadn't granted any clemencies.
"It's not an overnight process, but it's one that’s going to be thoughtful, and one that will be long-term enduring," Hochul assured the Queens Daily Eagle in July. "When I went through this process last December for the first time, I said, 'There's got to be a better way.' So, we are overhauling the system from the ground up."
No clemencies came after those comments either, until Wednesday, when the governor's team announced that 13 people would be receiving clemency—nine pardons, and four commutations.
According to Hochul's office, there were 861 commutation applications, and 450 pardon applications pending before yesterday's announcement; that means that the governor's mercy was shown to less than half of one percent of the people seeking commutation, and two percent of those seeking a pardon.
The governor's office did not answer our question about how many applications have been fully considered and rejected, but pointed to the fact that applicants now receive bi-annual letters regarding the status of their applications, and noted that two full-time employees—the director of clemency programs and the deputy director of clemency programs—have been hired to assist the executive office with processing applications.
Would Hochul support the currently pending legislation to release elderly New Yorkers from prison, or help ensure that incarcerated people receive fair and timely parole hearings? Her office only pledged to review anything that came across her desk.
Two of the four New Yorkers granted commutations, 60-year-old Jacqueline Smalls and 56-year-old Anthony Evans, will be released. The other two, 53-year-old Bruce Bryant and 60-year-old Stanley Bellamy, aren't even being released—they'll simply be permitted to go before the parole board much earlier than their previous sentence allowed for them. The parole board still may reject their pleas.
Victoria Law wrote about Bellamy's case for Hell Gate this past summer. He has been waiting since 2018 to hear back on his clemency application.
"I made a vow—even if I could never go home, I would do one thing to pay my debt back to the community and that was: prepare other men to go home," Bellamy told Hell Gate.
Jose DiLenola, the clemency campaign director for the Release Aging People in Prison Campaign, said in a statement that the 13 clemencies "should be celebrated."
"While our hearts break for those who are equally deserving of clemency and did not receive good news today, we double down on our commitment to keep fighting for their freedom," DiLenola said. "To that end, we look forward to Governor Hochul fulfilling her commitment to grant more clemencies on an ongoing basis."
—Nick Pinto and Christopher Robbins
Here are some more things that are also worth your attention:
- Remember earlier this month when people kept spotting FTX associate Caroline Ellison in locations near the U.S. Attorney's office in lower Manhattan and it seemed like huh, maybe this lady was cooperating? Yeah, she was snitching. Ellison and another FTX leader plead guilty yesterday as Sam Bankman-Fried was extradited back to the U.S. (And looked kinda better for it?) The U.S. Attorney for the Southern District said more indictments are on their way.
- Unrelatedly, here's a strange profile of a guy who took SBF's money and loves to poll, gamble, and hashtag.
- A 2022 opening of a tunnel that was originally set to open in 2009? Unlikely.
- Better weekend subway service, more bus service, and slightly crappier Monday/Friday service? Not til June.
- Steven Cohen is spending a lot of money on the Mets. This has made some fans uneasy, because they are conditioned to be losers. But we shouldn't lose sight of the fact that whatever Cohen might be "taxed" by Major League Baseball for spending too much money on baseball players, he'll more than make up for in profits for his imminent casino, for which we're apparently entering the "beg for scraps" phase.
- Speaking of losers (of local elections that is!), they keep finding their way into the Adams administration.
- The George Santos story keeps giving. Now only possibly gay, definitely not Jewish.
- Weeks after going into effect, the NYPD is finally beginning training on Mayor Adams's new involuntary commitment policy.
- After Eric Adams demanded new budget cuts, including cutting City Council members' discretionary funding, the relationship between the mayor and council chambers has reached new lows.
Thanks for reading!
Register or log in to continue.See all subscription options.
Stay in touch
Sign up for our free newsletter
More from Hell Gate
We Don’t Always Have to be Listening to the Same Frictionless R&B Everywhere
Update your playlists, they're making me feel bad.
Lower Manhattan’s Internet Is Down
"It's affecting multiple layers of government," one City Council staffer told us.
The NYPD Is Stopping More People in Eric Adams’s New York
Ten years after a federal court declared the NYPD's use of stop-and-frisk unconstitutional, street stops are on the rise.
A Taxonomy of the Names of the Roses in the Brooklyn Botanic Garden
Tag yourself, we're Comtesse Festetics Hamilton.
Why Does Eric Adams Think Migrants Are ‘Destroying’ New York?
Gaby Del Valle and Felipe De La Hoz join us to break down why the Adams administration has taken such a dramatic turn.