When did New York voters begin to turn on their five-term U.S. Senator Chuck Schumer?
Was it when he squandered Democratic leverage to hash out a deal to avoid a government shutdown last year? (Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez called that move a "betrayal.")
Or perhaps it was his April vote, along with just six other Democrats, to continue sending military bulldozers to Israel, at a moment when Americans are increasingly fed up with Israel's war in Gaza.
Maybe they thought Schumer had lost touch with reality when he refused to endorse Zohran Mamdani last year, a decision that was echoed in his failure to recognize other progressive juggernauts across the country before the 2026 midterms.
Or perhaps Schumer's appeal has been steadily ebbing for years, as his longstanding coziness with Wall Street feels wildly out of step at a time of surging economic populism and anger at a "rigged system." Schumer's daughters' employment at Facebook, Amazon, and, no kidding, OpenAI, certainly looks corrupt.
Whatever love we once felt for the avuncular retail politician known for his annual visits to each of New York's 62 counties, his high school graduation speeches, and his parade grand marshaling, New York is over it.
In his home state, his job approval rating bottomed out at 27 percent in February, according to Marist. A more recent Quinnipiac survey had him at 36 percent, but still underwater with 54 percent of New Yorkers polled disapproving of the job he's doing. "Poll after poll suggests that the American people want real change," Senator Bernie Sanders said at a recent press conference with Senator Elissa Slotkin as they called for new Senate leadership. We reached out to Schumer's team to run all this by them, and we'll update this story if they respond.


